On weekdays in early September, the gates at Sun & Surf Beach Club were closed to members so construction crews could rebuild the cabanas and lockers an August tornado had torn apart. On weekends, members came back to a cafeteria, a bar, and the Osprey deck, while the club's dining room held belongings salvaged from damaged cabanas.
Most years, Ocean Boulevard's clubs settle into the off-season right after the last September weekend, and the next summer more or less takes care of itself. This year, three of the best-known properties on the strip go into winter with questions still open. One is rebuilding. One is changing leadership. One is run by a receiver under bankruptcy court supervision while its land is for sale. What members find next Memorial Day depends on work, hearings, and decisions scheduled between now and January.
Fifty Cabanas and a Three-Week Estimate
The storm came through on August 20 with estimated peak winds of 97 mph. The Herald reported that it damaged 50 cabanas at Sun & Surf. Early counts were different. News 12 reported about 40 damaged cabanas, along with parts of several buildings. The worst damage was in cabanas and lockers E-21 through E-52 and F-33 through F-62. Some roofs were hit by debris and pieces of other structures that the wind picked up and dropped on them.
The club reopened in stages, and here is how the end of the season went:
- August 29 and 30: Partial reopening, with the cafeteria, bar, and Osprey deck open.
- Weekdays afterward: The club closed so construction crews could work safely on the damaged cabanas and lockers.
- Through September 13: Sun & Surf members could use Silver Point while work went on.
- The restaurant: Closed for the rest of the season, because its dining room was holding belongings from members whose cabanas were damaged. Reopening was expected next season.
In early September, Baumert told the Herald he hoped the rebuilding would be done "within the next three weeks." He also said the damaged cabanas would be rebuilt, with the extent of the work on each depending on its condition. As of October 11, no public report confirms that the work is finished. The Herald article is the latest detailed account, and it describes a club still clearing debris and starting construction.
"We want the people to see that we're not going anywhere," Baumert told the Herald. He also said neighboring businesses and other beach clubs had offered a lot of support after the storm.
Two Clubs, One President
Sun & Surf members could use Silver Point during the rebuild because the two clubs had the same president. William "Bill" Baumert led both, and after the storm he went to the scene and laid out a path to restoring the club, Newsday reported. Both clubs released statements honoring him as "a beloved fixture of summers at the beach."
His career covered more than six decades. According to Newsday, he grew up in Breezy Point, Queens, started as a lifeguard at Breezy Point Beach Club, moved into other roles there, and went on to a long career at oceanside clubs, where people called him "Mr. B." A memorial on Silver Point's homepage describes the same span, from Breezy Point to Silver Point and Sun & Surf.
"The clubs were as much a part of Mr. B's life as he was of theirs," the clubs' statements read. "He loved his members and took great pride in the relationships he built with them over the years."
That means a rebuild Baumert had planned out publicly in August will be finished under someone else. The clubs haven't said anything publicly about who will lead them next. It matters to anyone holding a cabana at either one, because the same person ran both properties.
Down the Boulevard, a Club Run Under Court Supervision
At 1751 Ocean Boulevard, the New York Beach Club has roughly 1,000 members and is going through something very different. The Real Deal reported in August that the club is for sale along with a nearby lot at 1815 Ocean Boulevard, which together come to about 11 acres of beachfront. The property used to be the New Plaza Beach Club. Hurricane Sandy destroyed it in 2012, and it was bought and renovated in 2016.
Per that report, here is how it got to this point. The club filed for Chapter 11 in February after defaulting on two loans totaling $10 million. Its filing lists about $900,000 in assets and more than $17 million in liabilities. The lender and the operator disagree about why payments stopped. The operator points to a January 2024 flood that he says required costly renovations, and the lender filed a foreclosure action in March 2024. A $30.5 million sale agreed in December 2025 was terminated in February. The original lender later sold its loan to an entity backed by Golden East Investors.
For members, the key point is that the club is still open for business. A court-appointed receiver runs it, and as of August it was taking deposits for the 2027 summer season. The property includes hundreds of cabanas, two pools, a tiki bar, beachfront dining, live music, and parking for about 500 cars.
The public bankruptcy docket has the latest. At a hearing on October 1, the receiver's term was extended, and an order signed October 2 keeps the receiver in possession of the property through January 31, 2027. A status hearing is set for November 5 at the federal courthouse in Central Islip. The docket lists a "Prospective Buyer" as an interested party without naming it, and the entries reviewed show no auction date, winning bid, or completed sale.
Catalina's Price Tag and the Zoning Question
The same Real Deal article mentioned that Catalina Beach Club, which sits on 6.5 acres, was listed for close to $30 million. The New York Beach Club's operator used that figure to estimate that his larger property could sell for as much as $50 million. No report since mid-August confirms a Catalina sale or contract.
That article also raised a larger question. The New York Beach Club property is zoned for marine recreation, and the operator described it as a rezoning opportunity for a developer interested in condominiums or apartments. That is the seller's own view, and nothing has been proposed. The Village Board's draft minutes from September 14 cover hearings on filming rules and on consolidating zoning-violation penalties. They don't mention rezoning beach-club land or any proposal to redevelop a club. As of now, the zoning that has kept these properties as cabanas and pools is still in place, and village records show no request to change it.
Two of the larger parcels on the strip are on the market at once, and neither has a confirmed buyer. Whoever ends up buying them will shape how that stretch of Ocean Boulevard looks and operates.
The Off-Season Calendar
Most of what happens next has a date attached, and a few routine village items fall in the same weeks.
| Date | What's scheduled | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Since October 1 | Atlantic Beach Bridge switches to openings on signal from 8 a.m. to midnight; openings between midnight and 8 a.m. need eight hours' notice | Nassau County Bridge Authority |
| Week of October 12 | Liberty Utilities starts replacing water mains on Genesee Boulevard and Fulton Avenue between Park Street and Ocean Boulevard, weather permitting | Village notice |
| October 15, 3 p.m. | Proposals due to manage and operate the Atlantic Beach Tennis Center | Village notice |
| October 19 | Village Board meeting; no agenda posted yet | Village meetings page |
| November 5, 10 a.m. | Status hearing in the New York Beach Club bankruptcy | Court docket |
| January 31, 2027 | End of the receiver's current extended term at New York Beach Club | Court docket |
The water main work is the one item here that will affect daily driving. Drivers should expect detours or closures along Genesee and Fulton, and the village says residents will get 24 hours' notice before any planned water shutoff. The tennis RFP fits the same pattern as the clubs. The Tennis Center is another warm-weather amenity whose operator for next season is being chosen in the off-season. The notice doesn't say whether anything about how it runs will change.
The bridge schedule stays the same every year. The on-signal rules run from October 1 through May 14. By the time the summer opening schedule comes back, Sun & Surf's rebuilt sections, its new leadership, and the New York Beach Club's ownership may be clearer. Until then, the November 5 hearing and the October 19 board meeting are the two dates where public information can change.
If you hold a cabana on Ocean Boulevard or own a home nearby and want to talk through how these changes might affect the strip next summer, Richard Baumel follows Atlantic Beach year-round and is glad to compare notes. Let's Connect.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.