Roslyn Country Club is the name on the civic association, the neighborhood website and the listing descriptions. The club itself, at 33 Club Drive, has been closed since 2007, according to Newsday. Buyers who tour this part of Roslyn Heights are paying for two other things. One is a lot laid out by Levitt & Sons in 1949. The other is whatever has been built on that lot since then.
That changes how you compare one house here with another. The neighborhood name tells you very little about price. Price depends on how far a house has grown past its original Levitt footprint and whether that growth is fully documented.
Club Membership Was Always Optional
Levitt & Sons finished the subdivision in 1949 with 668 homes, according to a 2003 Newsday account reprinted on the neighborhood's own site. Later Newsday coverage put the number at about 700. The houses were sold as modern, upscale homes for their day. A longtime resident interviewed by the Long Island Press in 2016 recalled at least three models: a single-level ranch, a model with a higher roof and attic space, and open plans she compared to Frank Lloyd Wright's work.
The club followed a different arrangement. Homeowners had the right to use it for an annual fee instead of being required to join, and that fee started at $100 a year. According to the 2003 Newsday account, the fee later went to $150 and then to $500. The property also changed owners in the early 2000s and ended up with Corona Realty of Mineola.
Newsday reported in 2016 that the club closed in 2007, after the owner sued residents over easement rights to the facilities and lost.
The Park Plan That Never Closed
In 2012 the Town of North Hempstead agreed to buy the club's 7.2 acres for $2 million and proposed a $14.2 million restoration called Levitt Park. The Town never completed the purchase. A 2020 decision from the New York State courts dismissed the Town's suit against Corona Realty Holding. The court found that a condition of the contract had not been met by its extended deadline and that Corona had ended the deal effective January 1, 2015.
Levitt Park does not appear on the Town's parks directory. The name does survive on paper. The Town's preliminary 2027 budget, dated October 13, 2026, lists a "Levitt Park at Roslyn Heights Park District" with no expenses or revenues budgeted for it.
For a buyer, this means the shared amenity built into the 1949 plan has been gone for almost two decades. Price in this section is set the same way it is for any single-family home, by the house and its lot. There is no club membership, no club dues and no club access to factor in. The name is history.
Value Has Moved Into Bigger Houses
As the club wound down, the houses kept getting bigger. The 2003 Newsday account described buyers purchasing older homes and tearing them down to rebuild. By 2016, the Long Island Press reported in "From Levitt to Lavish" that original Levitt houses were becoming rare because so many had been demolished and replaced with larger homes.
A current listing shows where pricing sits now. 57 Parkway Drive is described as a Roslyn Country Club cedar expanded ranch built in 1951, with four bedrooms, two and a half baths, about 2,300 square feet, a two-car garage and a one-third-acre lot. It was listed at $1,595,000 and is now under contract. That figure is an asking price, not a closed sale. For comparison, the Nassau County single-family median sale price for September 2026 was $860,000, up 2.1% from the year before, according to OneKey MLS's county report.
An expanded 1951 ranch asking close to twice the county median is not paying a premium for a club. The money is in the lot and in what was added to the house, so two homes on the same street can be priced far apart.
When an Expansion's Records Don't Match the House
Since expansion drives value here, the records behind an expansion matter as much as the square footage.
In July 2025, Newsday reported that some homes in the Town were enlarged in the early 2000s beyond what Town code allows, and that the Town building department issued certificates of occupancy for them anyway. Officials later said those certificates were issued in error, and many of the homes are in the Roslyn Country Club area. According to the same report, some owners have had trouble selling. On July 8, 2025, the Town board approved a 35% discount on the fees for new certificates. The Town Attorney said 22 homeowners were eligible, most of them in Roslyn Country Club.
The number of homes affected is small next to the size of the neighborhood. Still, the problem sits in the part of the house that carries the most value. If you're looking at an enlarged home here, ask when the work was done and request the documents for it early, the same way you'd ask about the roof or the boiler. This article is general information and not legal, tax or financial advice. Confirm the specifics of any property with an attorney and the appropriate professionals.
A Civic Association Instead of a Club
The organized side of neighborhood life now runs through the Roslyn Country Club Civic Association. Membership is optional. The Long Island Press reported in July 2025 that the association had been dormant until 2023, when it came back with a new board under president Alina Uzilov. At that point about 40% of residents were dues-paying members.
The association lists its results as new stop signs and traffic lights, sidewalk repairs, resurfaced roads, a new fence and ADA upgrades at Shepherd Lane Playground, and garbage pickups moved to later hours. Its long-term goals include expanding the playground. It has also opposed zoning changes and dense development that it says do not fit the neighborhood's character.
For a buyer, that tells you what kind of change is likely here. The association backs single-family homes on Levitt lots, which means demand will keep going into individual houses and not into new density. Your choice in this section comes down to the house: one already expanded, one with room to grow, or one of the original Levitt designs that remain.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do Roslyn Country Club homes come with club membership? No. Newsday reported that the club at 33 Club Drive closed in 2007. The Town's 2012 agreement to buy the site for a park was terminated by the seller effective January 1, 2015. Even when the club was open, homeowners had the right to join for an annual fee and were not required to.
How old are the houses? Levitt & Sons completed the subdivision in 1949. Many houses have since been expanded or replaced, so a listing's build year often reflects only the original structure. The expanded ranch at 57 Parkway Drive, for example, lists 1951.
Is there a neighborhood organization? Yes. The Roslyn Country Club Civic Association is listed with the Town of North Hempstead's civic associations, and membership is optional.
If you're comparing an expanded Levitt ranch with a rebuild in Roslyn Country Club, or deciding whether an original house is worth the work to expand, Richard Baumel can review the house, its records and its renovation potential with you before you decide what it's worth. Let's connect.