Canvas grocery tote, autumn fruit, herbs and artisan bread on a pale stone island in a bright, refined kitchen.

Hewlett's Grocery Map Now Runs Through Specialty Stores

This fall, workers took the King Kullen sign down from the building at 1765 Peninsula Blvd. The LI Herald photographed it coming off the facade. The supermarket closed on May 21 after 45 years in Hewlett. A company spokesperson said in an April statement that "lease options expired and we were unable to reach favorable lease renewal terms."

The next tenant is a thrift store. Savers has leased the space and expects to open in the second quarter of 2027.

The loss of one supermarket is part of a pattern that has played out around Hewlett over the past year. Every new grocer near Hewlett since late 2025 has been a specialty or international store, and the large conventional formats have closed or changed owners. The weekly shop still has places to go. It just has fewer one-stop supermarkets to choose from and more single-purpose stops.

Peninsula Boulevard Is Down to One Supermarket

The Herald's report on the closing named the nearest remaining supermarket as Foodtown, at 1368 Peninsula Blvd. in the Peninsula Shopping Center. A longtime shopper quoted in that story summed up the old arrangement in one line: "We have King Kullen and Foodtown. That's all our choices."

Since May, only half of that pair has remained. The good news is that Foodtown went into this year freshly rebuilt. In September 2024 the store, which is employee-owned, held a grand reopening after a full makeover. The work added a bakery department, a pizza oven, a sushi station and a new kitchen for hot foods, and other sections were expanded. Its parent company, PSK Supermarkets, remodels each of its stores on a 10-year rotation, according to the Herald's coverage of the reopening. As recently as October 17, Foodtown was advertising for a deli associate at the Hewlett store.

The closest King Kullen is now the Valley Stream store at 231 West Merrick Road. The Herald pointed to it as the alternative when the Hewlett closing was announced. Even that store is changing, as a later section explains.

The Grocers That Opened Are Specialists

The store that opened closest to Hewlett in the past year came to Broadway, not Peninsula Boulevard. NetCost Market opened its first Long Island location at 1296 Broadway on December 16, according to the Herald's January 2 report. The Herald's opening story describes a stock of American goods alongside Eastern European prepared foods like syrniki, zapekanka and cheburek. The store also carries Belgian chocolates, Baltic spreads, fresh caviar, several kinds of smoked fish, and cuts like rabbit legs and duck breast.

A similar store opened over the summer, a short drive southeast. GoStockUp opened a grocery at 3350 Lawson Blvd. in Oceanside, next door to the company's warehouse. According to the Herald, it carries Eastern European and international foods together with everyday staples. The business started as a wholesale distributor of European grocery products and began selling online in 2023 before it opened a storefront.

Meanwhile, the most high-tech conventional grocer in the area disappeared. Amazon Fresh's 47,300-square-foot store at 3620 Long Beach Road in Oceanside opened in July 2022 and had its last day on February 1, after Amazon announced it was closing its Amazon Fresh and Amazon Go stores nationwide.

So within about a year, two specialty grocers opened within a few miles of Hewlett, and two large conventional supermarkets closed: one on Peninsula Boulevard and one on Long Beach Road.

Why a Thrift Chain Signed the Lease

Newsday's report on the Savers lease explains the trend from both directions. King Kullen's Hewlett store was the 14th the company had closed since 2015, as traditional supermarket chains lose a growing share of food spending to discount and specialty grocers.

Savers, on the other hand, is growing. According to Newsday:

  • The Hewlett store will be Savers' ninth on Long Island. The eighth opened in Carle Place, in a former Big Lots space, the week before the Hewlett lease was reported.
  • The chain's U.S. net sales rose 11.6% to $255.3 million in its fiscal second quarter compared with the same period a year earlier, and sales at stores open at least a year rose 6.6%.
  • Savers collects donated clothing and household goods on behalf of nonprofits and pays its partners based on the weight of what comes in. Its Long Island partner for 29 years has been Big Brothers Big Sisters Long Island.

Savers also leased the freestanding former Chase Bank building, with its drive-through, at 1735 Peninsula Blvd. on the same property. Sean Elias of Elias Properties, the Jericho company that owns the center, told Newsday the chain hadn't yet decided how to use it. He said it could serve as a drop-off for donations "or whatever they decide to use it for." The bank closed a few years ago.

The neighborhood's reaction showed how much the supermarket was missed. According to the Herald, a post on its Facebook page asking for opinions on the lease drew more than 300 comments, and many of them said the site should go to another grocer. Commenters named Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace, Whole Foods or an Italian market as the kind of store they hoped would come instead. Those were wishes posted in a comment thread. The lease went to Savers.

The Valley Stream Store Just Changed Owners

King Kullen itself now has a new owner. Giunta's Meat Farms, based in Oakdale, completed its purchase of King Kullen Grocery Co. on October 3. The deal includes all 24 remaining King Kullen supermarkets and four Wild by Nature natural foods stores, every one of them on Long Island. Before the purchase, Giunta's ran 10 stores on the Island. In a joint statement, the two companies said King Kullen's primary challenges were "increased competition and rising operating costs."

News 12 reported that the company would decide over the coming months which stores keep the King Kullen name and which become Giunta's. That means the King Kullen on West Merrick Road in Valley Stream, now Hewlett's closest, is owned by a different company than it was when the Hewlett store closed in May.

The Weekly Shop, Store by Store

Here are the grocery stores around Hewlett, grouped by what kind of trip each one serves. Addresses come from each store's own locator or from local coverage.

Store Address What it is in 2026
Foodtown 1368 Peninsula Blvd., Hewlett Only remaining full-service supermarket on Hewlett's stretch of Peninsula Blvd.; renovated in 2024
NetCost Market 1296 Broadway, Hewlett Opened in December; Eastern European and imported specialties plus American staples
Trader Joe's 1280 West Broadway, Hewlett Produce, meat, bakery and staples
Gourmet Glatt 1030 Railroad Ave., Woodmere Kosher supermarket
Gourmet Glatt 137 Spruce St., Cedarhurst Kosher supermarket
Seasons 330 Central Ave., Lawrence Kosher supermarket
Stop & Shop 253-01 Rockaway Blvd., Woodmere Conventional supermarket
King Kullen 231 West Merrick Road, Valley Stream Nearest King Kullen; now owned by Giunta's Meat Farms
Lidl 492 Atlantic Ave., East Rockaway Discount supermarket with produce, meat and daily essentials
Stop & Shop 3577 Long Beach Road, Oceanside Conventional supermarket
Stop & Shop 465 Atlantic Ave., Oceanside Conventional supermarket
GoStockUp 3350 Lawson Blvd., Oceanside Opened by July 2026; Eastern European and international foods

The table shows how much the specialty side has grown. Within Hewlett itself, Broadway now has two specialty grocers a few doors apart, NetCost at 1296 and Trader Joe's at 1280 West Broadway. On Hewlett's stretch of Peninsula Boulevard, which once had two full-service supermarkets, Foodtown is the only one left. For a conventional chain supermarket, the nearest options are now in Woodmere, Valley Stream, East Rockaway and Oceanside.

Savers expects to open at 1765 Peninsula Blvd. in the second quarter of 2027.

Richard Baumel follows the leases and storefronts along Peninsula Boulevard and Broadway as closely as the homes on the streets behind them, because both shape what daily life in Hewlett looks like. If you'd like to talk through how the changes on your part of Hewlett may play out over the next year, let's connect.

Work With Richard

Whether you’re buying, selling, or investing in New York real estate, Richard Baumel is committed to providing personalized guidance, local expertise, and a seamless experience from start to finish. Get in touch today to start your next move with confidence.

Follow Me on Instagram